Private Peaceful... from book to movie - Noah

I thought that the Private Peaceful movie was better than the book. It was a bit different from the book but is still enjoyed the movie aswell as the book. I think that when people change a book to a movie, they need to be careful about how much they change from the book. I would rate the movie 8/10 and I would rate the book 7/10. I think that if I made a stopmotion I would make it of Charlie being shot, or the soldiers charging with their bayonets.