Private Peaceful... from Book to Movie-Judd

The character that really nailed it for me in the movie was Charlie Peaceful because he always helped Tomo out and then he got killed by firing sqaud. The scene that I thought that was strange that the director added was when Sergeant Hanley was crawling back to the trench and Charlie raised his rifle and didn't shoot, but still he accused Charlie of cowardice. An important scene that was missed out was when Tomo saw Charlie and Mollie together without him knowing. I rate the book and movie 10/10 overall because it was very realistic and actual happened in World War 1. If I made a stop/motion scene from Private Peacful would be when they were hiding in the crator.